About Me

Name: Young Democrat
Biography
Loading...

Create Your Own Blog Find Other Townhall Blogs

Comments

Archives

Scalia Is Pro-Choice

                                                At least this sign is spelled correctly.
 
 

I'm starting a new series of posts on my blog to explain why I believe everyone should be politically pro-choice, if personally pro-life. For quick background, I was a member of Right to Life for ten years before joining Planned Parenthood a year and a half ago.

   Anthony Scalia, it is fair to say is the most conservative Supreme Court justice on the court today. So with the recent debate over President Obama's visit at Notre Dame, it has brought back that hottest of hot button issues, abortion into the national dialogue. When looking at this issue, those who are "Pro-Life" need to look at the law and not their emotions, many of which I share.

   Of course as you know, Roe vs. Wade said that a woman had a right to an abortion under the constitutional right to privacy in a 7-2 decision. That decision was reaffirmed in Casey vs. Planned Parenthood in a 6-3 decision. But what kind of right did Roe and Casey establish? It was a federal right to an abortion, meaning that every woman would get the equal opportunity to end her pregnancy regardless of which state she lived in. But what about those who voted against Roe and Casey, didn't they vote against abortion? No, those would held the minority opinion supported a state right to an abortion.

   During this contentious issue we have been having an argument over morality when in reality it is all about a debate over federal versus state law. In fact Anthony Scalia said in his recent interview with "60 Minutes", that he rejected the entire Right to Life legal argument that the equal protection clause of the constitution protected the unborn. He said that violated that original intent of the clause, and that argument was unconstitutional. Scalia saying that meant he considered abortion to be a federalist issue only and that the constitution protects the right to an abortion. Yet Scalia is considered be the most "pro-life" judge. It's because many in the pro-life and even the pro-choice argument have looked at the issue too emotionally, at the end of the day it is all about law. Scalia is pro-choice.

Email ItEmail It | Print ItPrint It | CommentsComments (5) | TrackbacksTrackbacks (0) | Flag as offensiveFlag as Offensive

Jim Bunning's Home Run

 
 

In Kentucky, there is a brawl a brewing and it's between the state's two Republican Senators, Mitch McConnell and Jim Bunning. A lot of it stems with Bunning, who is considered slightly unhinged and is angry over the fact that McConnell has not been as supportive to Bunning's 2010 re-election race instead trying to recruit other GOP candidates to beat him in the 2010 GOP Primary. In McConnell's defense, it's because Bunning barely won a squeaker in 2004 when Bush won the state in a landslide. In other words it's not a Republican thing it's a Bunning issue.

Still loyalty is a trait foreign to Washington but what's so much fun about this story now is the fact that Bunning is trying now out in the open to get McConnell removed as majority leader. It's a move I would favor; McConnell's has been a failure as minority leader and no where near as good as Former Senator Bill Frist. John Ensign of Nevada would be the best of a whole lot of rotten apples. He seems to have a good head on his shoulders and could be the "newer" face of the Republican Party. Sorry we don't have any new ones.

As the old saying goes "Even a broken clock tells the time for two minutes a day" such is the case with Jim Bunning. He said "Mitch McConnell has not shown leadership. In 2004 we had 55 Senate seats today we have 40, having lost 15 Senate seats under McConnell’s leadership. In 2010 we're most likely to lose 4 (that's true) and be down to 36. That's not any kind of leadership I want". I'm paraphrasing here but that is what he said. I'm going to say it again; the Republican Party leadership does not exist to make sure the party is pure conservative. It exists to get its members elected until the get the majority of seats. Being down to 40 and most likely down to 36 (that will be the bottom) is not leadership. The strategy being used by the Republican Party leadership is to wait and pounce on failure. That's terrible. We should be trying to come about with solutions that work to the problems Americans are faced with. Not only that but many in the GOP leadership only given conservative ideas lip service but continue to support the high spending in Washington. No one in GOP leadership has talked, proposed, or even thrown the idea out there of how to cut entitlement spending. Bunning is right on this one; McConnell needs to step down as minority leader giving the spot to Senator John Ensign.

Email ItEmail It | Print ItPrint It | CommentsComments (2) | TrackbacksTrackbacks (0) | Flag as offensiveFlag as Offensive
« Previous1Next »